I don’t even remember the last time I’ve wholeheartedly enjoyed a Bones episode, with no caveats, and no need to mull it over to let it sink in before I figure out I liked it.
This episode was Bones at its best (or should I say, at its best when things are at their worst in its own universe), and I’m just blown away by how riveted I was by the hour.
I felt for everyone. For Brennan, who immediately tempered the elation of her good news with worry over her husband’s demons. For Booth — poor, stupid, beautiful Booth — who was so obviously struggling with his impulses and in such complete denial that he was in trouble that he had to turn back into That Person. For Aubrey, who recognized the warning signs and was projecting what it was like for the other side for a dose of humility. And for the rest of the team, who awkwardly had to witness what seemed like Booth’s relapse, but then see him be a “good man” and right himself — only to not realize there’s a whole other gong show waiting for them down the road.
This is Booth from pre-Pilot/100th episode flashbacks, who didn’t have a gambling problem because he didn’t lose. This is Booth who hasn’t dealt with any of the shit he’s gone through in the last six months, to the point where he needs his new underling to flash a neon sign at him. This is Booth who is so terrified at the reality of his situation that he has to lie to himself, so that he can believe the lies he tells his wife. This is the Booth who so desperately needs to think he’s in control, that he’s going to prove just how in-control he is by betting again. Because he fucking walked away, dammit — and that means he’s strong enough.
(I had a whole speculation post I wrote privately on Tumblr the other day about how I can now actually see this story not being a complete train wreck the way I thought it would be initially, but that’s neither here nor there.)
Look, I’ve said many times I’m not looking forward to this story. I still think the timing is off (particularly if the show doesn’t get picked up for season 11), and there should have been a hell of a lot more buildup. (Let’s face it, the show’s been big on “telling, not showing” for years; hell, Booth and Brennan’s supposedly awesome sex life is the biggest abuser of this crutch, and it’s driven me a little up the wall, but I made my peace with that back in season 7.) I’m not going to placate myself by saying “it’s soooooo worth it because the actors are going to knock it out of the park!!!!” because I don’t think the ends always justify the means. (A shit story is still a shit story no matter who’s delivering it.)
BUT — and this is a big BUT — I guess I’m pleasantly surprised by the nuance I’ve seen, so far. Because I could see Booth cracking, and I can see, for now, how he can delude himself; he’s not going full-on card sharp. This probably isn’t any worse, in his mind, than fantasy football pools. David Boreanaz and Emily Deschanel did deliver amazing performances, and I do think the writers did a pretty good job of delving into the addict’s mind, without having Booth end up passed out in a gutter like a hobo.
It’s absolutely hard to watch, and I’m sure it’ll only get worse before it gets better. But I’m cautiously optimistic now in a way that I wasn’t a few weeks ago. Because the parts of the whole, here, were fantastic. For once, I had no major gripes, in a season where even episodes I enjoyed made me roll my eyes at least a few times. I couldn’t look away, and it made me feel that spark I’ve been missing all year. This is my show, the one I fangirled over and learned social media for and couldn’t wait to talk about immediately afterwards to the detriment of, you know, my actual work.
If it takes this doozy to keep me interested in the rest of the season? Well then, fine, Show, you win, lay it on me.
Because being sad is so much better than being dead inside, right?